Place before price

Picking donor sites for your state and town

A bakery in Duluth and a law office in Phoenix need different links. Here is how to match donors to your place, using the filters we actually have.

Brass compass pointing between city and town models on wood

Plain answer

Match the donor to the customer, not to the map

Among local link building tips, this one comes first: most of the lift comes from relevance to your trade and your region. The marketplace filters by niche, language, Domain Rating, traffic and price. It has no state filter, so you read each donor's own pages to see where it sits.

  • Open the donor's About page and a few articles
  • Look for named towns, counties or school districts
  • Skip any site that covers every state with the same text

What a place usually needs

General patterns from how local search works. Your market may differ.
Where you areWhat helps mostWhat wastes money
Big metro, such as Chicago or HoustonTrade and neighbourhood sites, plus a few strong niche donorsBroad news sites with no local angle
Mid-size city, such as Boise or TulsaCity guides, school and club sites, one regional paperDozens of cheap links on random topics
Small town under 20,000 peopleThe town paper, the chamber, the high school booster pagePaying $200 for one link when $20 would do
Statewide service, such as roofing across OhioTrade sites that mention the state, plus one page per metroOne generic page for the whole state
Gardener pruning roots of a rose bush with tools nearby

Reading a donor's location by hand

Open the site and scroll. A real local publisher names streets, teams and events. It will mention the county fair or the new overpass, and a copy-paste site will not.

Then check the language column in the marketplace, because English alone is not much of a filter in America. Use niche as your main lever, and match it to the service you sell, whether that is dental, roofing, tax prep or pet care.

Domain Rating helps, but it is an Ahrefs metric and it says nothing about town. A DR 25 site that your neighbours read can beat a DR 60 site they have never heard of. Judge by who reads it.

A fifteen-minute shortlist

  1. 1

    Write your service area

    List the cities, counties and the one state you serve. Keep it to ten names at most.

  2. 2

    Filter by niche and price

    Set a price ceiling first. With $100, aim for rows under $25 and see what remains.

  3. 3

    Open ten donors

    Read one article on each. Drop anything that looks stuffed with unrelated topics.

  4. 4

    Add the best five to the basket

    Nothing is charged at this step. Sleep on it and come back.

A note on Google's own words

Google's link spam update of December 2022 and the March 2024 core and spam updates both target links made to manipulate rankings. Relevance and real readers are the safe harbour, though no one can promise safety.

How to read a rival's local links before you buy

Before you pick a donor, look at who links to the pages that outrank you. Choose three or four rivals who show in the map pack for your main service. Their links usually come from places a customer could also visit, such as a town paper, a chamber listing or a trade group. Copy the pattern.

Here is a quick way. It takes one afternoon. Open the rival's site, then search the business name in quotes. Read the first two pages of results and keep a note of every site that mentions them. Ignore the directories you already know about.

Start with three or four rivals

Look at the businesses that show in the map pack for your main service in your town. Open their sites and note which outside pages mention them. Write them down. Does the list look like a trade directory, a town calendar or a club page? That answer tells you what kind of donor already works for them.

Be picky, always. A rival with twenty links from one tourism site may have a story you cannot repeat. If a source has no real reason to mention you, leave it on the list and move on.

Free routes are slower, and that is fine

Ahrefs and Semrush show referring domains for any page, but both are paid products. A cheaper route is to search the rival's exact business name in quotes. Searching by hand is slow. It still shows you where a paper or a club has written about them.

Mentions are not links. A town paper that names a rival without linking still tells you which outlets cover that trade. Note it. Then ask the paper for a link the next time you have real news to share.

Sort the list by place, not by score

Put each candidate on one of three lists: same town, same county, or same state. Keep it simple. A donor on the town list is the strongest fit for a shop that serves the town. A donor on the state list is a weaker one, unless your trade really does cover the whole state.

Say you run a plumbing firm in one county seat. Plain enough. A link from a county fair guide or a school booster page belongs on the first list. A link from a statewide home-improvement blog belongs lower, even if its Domain Rating looks better.

Three slips we see on place-based plans

Chasing the state capital

A link from a big city site does little for a business that serves a town two hours away.

Trusting the word local

Many sites say local in the title and publish the same text for fifty towns. Read before you buy.

Forgetting the page

A link to a thin page wastes the click. Build the page first, then link to it.

Stone bridge connecting urban buildings and rural town with boat

What makes a donor count as local to your customers

A site can be local without saying the word local. Look for details a neighbour would notice. Nothing fancy. Named streets, a council meeting summary, a high school sports column and photos of the county fair all point to a real place.

Relevance is a judgement. Not a number. The marketplace shows Domain Rating and traffic on every row, and both are useful. Neither one tells you whether a donor's readers live near your door, so you still read the page yourself.

Local ties a donor can show

Check the about page, the footer and the contact details. A real local publisher usually lists a street address, a phone with an area code and a list of staff. A network site often hides all three behind a form. Missing all three? Walk away.

Then read three recent articles. If each one names a different town, the site is probably writing for everywhere at once. Pick the donor that writes about one place with depth, and traffic can be smaller.

Regional publishers can be worth more

When a regional publisher has a working newsroom, it can beat ten niche blogs for your town. Real reporters matter. Its readers include the people who hire trades, buy from shops and recommend services at church or the rec centre.

Does the site carry a byline and a date? Are the stories about the state capital or about your county? Ask them first. Those are good questions before the basket.

Watch for the copy-paste town page

Some donors publish a town page for every place in America. Same text. Only the town name changes. Google's spam policies describe that kind of template as a pattern to avoid, so a link on one of those pages does little for you.

Open two town pages. If the second one repeats the first word for word, skip the donor. Spend the money on a page that reads as if someone walked the streets.

Questions owners ask about picking donors by place

Should I only buy links from sites in my own state?

Not always. A state filter does not exist in the marketplace, so you check each donor yourself. If the site serves your town, its state matters less. A county paper in a neighbouring state can still be the right fit for a store near the border.

How many donors should I look at before I buy?

Ten is a fair start for a small plan. Read one article on each, drop anything stuffed with unrelated topics, and keep the best five. More than that and most owners stop reading carefully, which defeats the point of the check.

Does a local link beat a big national link?

For a business that serves one area, a link from a place your customers visit often matters more than a famous name. A national site can still help, but it rarely sends a neighbour to your door. Judge each donor by its readers.

What if my service area covers several states?

Treat each state as its own small campaign, with its own list and its own budget. Start in the state where most of your calls come from. Add the second state only after you have checked the first set of links in Search Console.

Can I use keyword research tools to find local donors?

Yes. Many owners pair local link building tips with a keyword tool, then look at the sites that rank for their service in town. Use the tool to find candidates, then read the candidates yourself. A list of names is not a judgement of fit.

When one state is not enough

A state is a coarse unit, and a county or a metro area is often a better one. Pick the smallest area where you really do business.

Some owners serve two or three states, such as a moving company near the Georgia and Alabama line. Treat each state as its own small campaign.

Start where the phone rings most. Spend the first $100 there. Two or three links in each of two states beat one link in six places. Then review Search Console after a few weeks and see which city page gained impressions.

The city page guide covers how to build one landing page per place, and the budget page shows how to split the money. For the free routes, read about local newspapers next.